Steven MalloyBig Rapids Realty, REALTOR®

231-218-4605

202 Butler Street, Saugatuck, MI 49453

Show Map
$1,575,000
Mortgage Calculator
  • Bedrooms  
  • Bathrooms 1
  • SQ. FT.  
  • Schools Saugatuck-Douglas
  • County Allegan
  • Township Saugatuck City
  • Above Grade Sq. Ft.  
  • Below Grade Sq. Ft.  
  • Bedrooms  
  • Bathrooms 1 (F)
  • Basement  
  • Garage  
  • Acreage 0.11
  • Heat Type Forced Air
  • Central Air Central Air
  • Year Built 1851
  • Style  
  • Exterior  
  • Taxes 17017
  • SEV 309100
  • Zoning  
  • Parcel 57-300-146-00
  • Lot Size 69X68

Features

BUILDING ONLY FOR SALE. BUSINESS IS NOT FOR SALE. PLEASE DO NOT DISTURB TENANT.
202 Butler Street, (Commonly known as ''Pumpernickel's''), is one of the premier buildings in Downtown Saugatuck, on the busiest corner for both foot traffic and drive by traffic in town. It also has more outside exposed seating than any other restaurant on the main street in Saugatuck, (which is Butler Street). Pumpernickel's Restaurant has successfully operated out of this historic building for approximately 40 years. Additionally, it is one of the most historic buildings, dating back to 1840. Just for some historical perspective, at the time 202 Butler was built, there were only 26 States in the Union. Michigan being the most recent state added on January, 26th, 1837. See historical pictures provided.

Directions I-196 to Exit 36, turn West on Blue Star Hwy towards Saugatuck/Douglas. Turn West on Lake Street to Butler. Turn North/Right on Butler Street. Go one block to building.
Listing Courtesy of Joseph Kendrick - USRealty.com LLP

The content relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the IDX program of the Michigan Regional Information Center, LLC. © 2025 MichRIC, LLC. All rights reserved.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.